145 books
—
201 voters
Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “An Untamed State” as Want to Read:
An Untamed State
by
Roxane Gay (Goodreads Author)
Roxane Gay is a powerful new literary voice whose short stories and essays have already earned her an enthusiastic audience. In An Untamed State, she delivers an assured debut about a woman kidnapped for ransom, her captivity as her father refuses to pay and her husband fights for her release over thirteen days, and her struggle to come to terms with the ordeal in its afte
...more
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Reader Q&A
To ask other readers questions about
An Untamed State,
please sign up.
Popular Answered Questions
Kate
I couldn't put it down, actually. I thought it was beautiful, complicated, and sad.
Community Reviews
(showing 1-30)
Pretty decent debut novel. Protagonist loves to exhale.
People will tell you this book is about a kidnapping -- about the life before for its heroine, Mireille, and about the life after. People will tell you this book about Haiti -- about another lightning rod that divides asunder: class. It is about these things. It's about many other things, also. Depending on who you are, you may need a trigger warning, a stiff drink, a shower when you're reading (and after).
I just needed silence. And then I needed to talk. A lot. Not about the book, but about a ...more
I just needed silence. And then I needed to talk. A lot. Not about the book, but about a ...more
Disappointing read. Powerful subject matter reduced to Lifetime movie-worthy prose. Gay has a need to make every line a grand pronouncement, every scene worthy of a Tumblr "like." I found the book to be very emotionally manipulative (along the lines of a Nicholas Sparks novel). I hope no one confuses what I'm saying as a critique of emotions pursuant to kidnapping, or rape, or PTSD, or Miri's feelings about the horror she went through. I have no qualms with any of that. I am taking issue with th
...more
Favorite Book of the Year
Today I noticed a weird bruise on my finger. After talking myself down from a leukemia diagnosis, I finally figured out it was a Kindle-related injury. I had gripped my Kindle so hard while reading An Untamed State that I bruised my finger. That’s how powerful this book is—it can cause bruises! Puts a whole new meaning to the phrase, “this book is gripping!”
To quote another reviewer, what a mother-fucking masterpiece! The book grabs you immediately, and with each chapter ...more
Today I noticed a weird bruise on my finger. After talking myself down from a leukemia diagnosis, I finally figured out it was a Kindle-related injury. I had gripped my Kindle so hard while reading An Untamed State that I bruised my finger. That’s how powerful this book is—it can cause bruises! Puts a whole new meaning to the phrase, “this book is gripping!”
To quote another reviewer, what a mother-fucking masterpiece! The book grabs you immediately, and with each chapter ...more
Once upon a time, in a far-off land, I was kidnapped by a gang of fearless yet terrified young men with so much impossible hope beating inside their bodies it burned their very skin and strengthened their will right through their bones.
They held me captive for thirteen days.
They wanted to break me.
It was not personal.
I was not broken.
This is what I tell myself.
So begins this book. Mireille and her husband Michael along with her toddler son are visiting her family in Haiti. A group of men kidnap ...more
Find all of my reviews at: http://52bookminimum.blogspot.com/
“Once upon a time, my life was a fairy tale and then I was stolen from everything I’ve ever loved. There was no happily ever after. After days of dying, I was dead.”
You ever find yourself wanting to read something that makes you look a little like this . . .
If so, then An Untamed State might be the book for you.
While vacationing at her parents’ mansion in Haiti, Mireille and her husband decide to take their baby to the beach. Once ...more
“Once upon a time, my life was a fairy tale and then I was stolen from everything I’ve ever loved. There was no happily ever after. After days of dying, I was dead.”
You ever find yourself wanting to read something that makes you look a little like this . . .
If so, then An Untamed State might be the book for you.
While vacationing at her parents’ mansion in Haiti, Mireille and her husband decide to take their baby to the beach. Once ...more
I won this book through a Goodreads Giveaway. I was excited because I was already familiar with Roxane Gay's writing (fiction & nonfiction), had read Ayiti, and was already a fan.
I want to say honestly that this book rattled me. I cried through the last 1/3 and after finishing I was awake for several hours thinking about it. Few books do this for me. I took copious notes while I read. As a reader, I was fully engaged with this story all throughout. Fully there with Mireille and the other ch ...more
I want to say honestly that this book rattled me. I cried through the last 1/3 and after finishing I was awake for several hours thinking about it. Few books do this for me. I took copious notes while I read. As a reader, I was fully engaged with this story all throughout. Fully there with Mireille and the other ch ...more
The reviews and cover blurbs led me to expect a serious literary tale of kidnapping and the class divisions between the wealthy and poor in Haiti. But what I got instead was a Lifetime movie of the week. (There's certainly nothing wrong with Lifetime movies if you know that's what to expect).
Chapters alternated between the present day kidnapping and flashbacks to the past, mostly telling the tale of when Mireille and her husband met and married. The scenes with the kidnappers were brutal and gr ...more
Chapters alternated between the present day kidnapping and flashbacks to the past, mostly telling the tale of when Mireille and her husband met and married. The scenes with the kidnappers were brutal and gr ...more
Haiti. "A country of contrast between beauty and brutality". Impoverished. Overpopulated. Oppressed. Unbearable heat. A country’s whose industry is abduction. This is where the story starts. For Mierelle, an American visiting her Haitian family, she becomes the currency being negotiated. Her father refuses to be comply with the $1M ransom. The cost: Thirteen days of sexual and psychological trauma. Thirteen days of dying. A lifetime to recover. In the before, life was a fairytale. In the after,
...more
An Untamed State is an extremely hard, brutal, and fierce read. It took me inside the horrible kidnappings going on inside Haiti daily. Searching Google, I found the estimate to be 160 a day. These kidnappings are done to force the wealthy to pay for their loved one's return. The extreme discrepancy between rich and poor in Haiti is astounding. While America is not a third world country, it forced me to think of growing disparities in my own country.
Roxane Gay tells the story of one families or ...more
Roxane Gay tells the story of one families or ...more
Roxane Gay doesn’t make it easy to recommend her riveting first novel. Set in modern-day Haiti, “An Untamed State” is the story of an American lawyer who’s kidnapped while visiting her rich parents in Port-au-Prince. For more than 200 pages, she’s beaten, burned, sliced and gang-raped. Owing to the power of Gay’s prose, the immediacy of the narrator’s voice and the graphic nature of this ordeal, it’s some of the most emotionally exhausting material I’ve ever read.
I have serious reservations abou ...more
I have serious reservations abou ...more
An Untamed State
Roxane Gay, is an American writer, professor, editor, blogger, and commentator
The U.S. official Government policy concerning the release of prisoners and demands for ransoms reads:
The U.S. Government will make no concessions to terrorists holding official or private U.S. citizens hostage. It will not pay ransom, release prisoners, change its policies, or agree to other acts that might encourage additional terrorism.
There's of course a significant difference in the way we thin ...more
Roxane Gay, is an American writer, professor, editor, blogger, and commentator
The U.S. official Government policy concerning the release of prisoners and demands for ransoms reads:
The U.S. Government will make no concessions to terrorists holding official or private U.S. citizens hostage. It will not pay ransom, release prisoners, change its policies, or agree to other acts that might encourage additional terrorism.
There's of course a significant difference in the way we thin ...more
A disclosure: as an editor I published a short story that grew into this novel, and since then the author has become a friend. So while I wouldn't review this for publication, I'll do so here with that caveat.
This was a difficult read, because it is brutal and its brutality is offered in a matter-of-fact way that while anything but superficial is very clear about the surface of things, the physical, painful reality of experience. As a reader I'm more often drawn to the absurd, to fiction a step ...more
This was a difficult read, because it is brutal and its brutality is offered in a matter-of-fact way that while anything but superficial is very clear about the surface of things, the physical, painful reality of experience. As a reader I'm more often drawn to the absurd, to fiction a step ...more
this is a brutal and unsparing portrayal of sexual violence. it's also a critique of economic disparity and an angry indictment of patriarchy (which may or may not go hand in hand with economic disparity).
a young haitian lawyer, black, married to a handsome nebraskan man (white), with an übercute little kid, is kidnapped during her visit to haiti to see her family. kidnapping apparently is the order of the day in haiti at the time (pre-earthquake) and wealthy people expect it and do all they ca ...more
a young haitian lawyer, black, married to a handsome nebraskan man (white), with an übercute little kid, is kidnapped during her visit to haiti to see her family. kidnapping apparently is the order of the day in haiti at the time (pre-earthquake) and wealthy people expect it and do all they ca ...more
The Hook - ”Once upon a time in a far-off land, I was kidnapped by a gang of fearless yet terrified young men with so much impossible hope beating inside their bodies it burned their very skin and strengthened their will right through their bones.”
The Line – ”The people love a real tragedy when they think it cannot happen to them.
The Sinker – Many young girls look up to their fathers. Fathers are larger than life, not only in stature but often also in voice. Fathers can do no wrong and in my cas ...more
The Line – ”The people love a real tragedy when they think it cannot happen to them.
The Sinker – Many young girls look up to their fathers. Fathers are larger than life, not only in stature but often also in voice. Fathers can do no wrong and in my cas ...more
Look, I know this is fiction, but if you told me that this was actually a memoir published as fiction, I would believe it. Every second of this book feels like reality. All the senses are triggered: You feel everything, hear everything, smell everything, taste everything. Miri once lived a perfect fairy tale life. And then she visited her family in Haiti and was kidnapped and held for ransom for thirteen days. Unspeakable horrors were done to her, while her wealthy father tries to negotiate the
...more
I am utterly baffled by these rave reviews. Were we reading the same book? Honestly this reads more like a Sidney Sheldon novel than the timely sociopolitical thriller I thought it would be. The relationship between Mireille and Michael was immature, one dimensional and unrealistic--much like the characters in this book. And as another reader pointed out was the issue of race and how it was portrayed in such a simplistic, clumsy, and dare say, slavish adoration of the white American male. It fel
...more
Just, holy jesus. Destroyed me. "Unflinching" is the first most obvious word that comes to mind when you're reading a writer who is so unafraid to write into truly horrifying things. The story is horrifying, unbelievable but so believable, yet told so skillfully that there's never a question of not turning the page, of not finding out what happens next. But as difficult as the story is, it was the tiny little moments of tenderness that broke me. The relationship between Mireille and Lorraine is
...more
This is really an appalling book. It appears to be a fictionalization of this kidnapping,
http://www.miaminewtimes.com/2011-01-...
but Gay transforms the mafia kidnappers into leftist militants and brutal rapists. The resulting story is dominantly disavowed BDSM erotica, but it serves also as reactionary propaganda. The title should tip anyone off to the hackneyed neo-colonial comic that's coming: there's nothing even hipster-ironic here to mitigate the reasserted formula -- Haiti = Savage, and ...more
http://www.miaminewtimes.com/2011-01-...
but Gay transforms the mafia kidnappers into leftist militants and brutal rapists. The resulting story is dominantly disavowed BDSM erotica, but it serves also as reactionary propaganda. The title should tip anyone off to the hackneyed neo-colonial comic that's coming: there's nothing even hipster-ironic here to mitigate the reasserted formula -- Haiti = Savage, and ...more
This is the very disturbing story of a woman (Mireille) kidnapped for ransom in Haiti. The story moves back and forth in time. Mireille tells the story of her kidnapping, her life "before" and her life "after". There are brutal scenes of rape and torture but it tells the story of Mireille and her husband Michael's love. I did not really "like" most of the characters in the book (including Mireille). I found myself getting very frustrated with Mireille in the "after" but that being said, I cannot
...more
An Untamed State is a novel that spotlights victims of trauma and their road to recovery. The central character, Mirielle, is the American-born daughter of Haitian parents. Her parents, born from humble beginnings eventually move back to Haiti to continue their prosperous business ventures. While visiting her parents with her husband and infant son, Mireille is kidnapped, repeatedly gang-raped, physically and psychologically tortured for nearly two weeks because her father refuses to pay the ran
...more
2.5 stars.
I was looking forward to reading this for quite some time. It wasn’t really ‘hype’ but I felt an expectation with this one. I didn’t enjoy it as much as I’d hoped. I wasn’t fazed with the violence, but I absolutely wasn’t a fan of either of our main players here, Mireille or Michael. I lagged about half way through, and mostly read to finish, not to enjoy.
Mireille is a Haitian woman, who’s happy living in Miami with her adoring husband Michael. She is kidnapped outside of her parents ...more
I was looking forward to reading this for quite some time. It wasn’t really ‘hype’ but I felt an expectation with this one. I didn’t enjoy it as much as I’d hoped. I wasn’t fazed with the violence, but I absolutely wasn’t a fan of either of our main players here, Mireille or Michael. I lagged about half way through, and mostly read to finish, not to enjoy.
Mireille is a Haitian woman, who’s happy living in Miami with her adoring husband Michael. She is kidnapped outside of her parents ...more
Horrible things happen in this book but you know that because you've read the back flap.
What stays with me, though, is the treatment of race in this novel. I can't get over it. I feel like I read a book trying to convince me of the goodness of one white man and then the goodness of one true blue white American family, and then the goodness of a corn husking white community.
It is a brutal novel, of course it is, it's about a 13 day kidnapping and rape, but even in this brutality, in a story where ...more
What stays with me, though, is the treatment of race in this novel. I can't get over it. I feel like I read a book trying to convince me of the goodness of one white man and then the goodness of one true blue white American family, and then the goodness of a corn husking white community.
It is a brutal novel, of course it is, it's about a 13 day kidnapping and rape, but even in this brutality, in a story where ...more
Once upon a time, in a far-off land, I was kidnapped by a gang of fearless yet terrified young men with so much impossible hope beating inside their bodies that it burned their very skin and strengthened their will right through their bones.
Damn. I read An Untamed State over a period of two weeks, taking in the torturous first half at a snail's pace, speeding through the second half in an emotion-filled haze. The book follows Mirelle Jameson, daughter of one of Haiti's richest sons, wife to Mich ...more
Damn. I read An Untamed State over a period of two weeks, taking in the torturous first half at a snail's pace, speeding through the second half in an emotion-filled haze. The book follows Mirelle Jameson, daughter of one of Haiti's richest sons, wife to Mich ...more
Roxane Gay (n. 1974) é uma proeminente intelectual norte-americana – professora, jornalista, editora e escritora – que publica em 2014 o seu primeiro romance ”Um Estado Selvagem” no original ”An Untamed State”.
Mireille Duval Jameson é a filha mais nova de um dos homens mais ricos do Haiti, Sebastien Duval, um próspero construtor civil, que fizera fortuna nos Estados Unidos da América; que estudou advocacia numa universidade norte-americana, casou com um Michael, têm um filho ainda bebé, e que vi ...more
Plot Spoilers Ahead: Read at Your Own Discretion
When I first read about An Untamed State, I decided it wouldn’t be the book for me. References to the scenes of graphic violence were enough to turn me away. But as Roxane Gay’s star continued to rise this past year and I read more of her columns, followed her on Twitter (there are few reasons for hanging out on Twitter, but Roxane is one of them), and became enamored of her voice and her personal politics in Bad Feminist, I turned back to An Unt ...more
When I first read about An Untamed State, I decided it wouldn’t be the book for me. References to the scenes of graphic violence were enough to turn me away. But as Roxane Gay’s star continued to rise this past year and I read more of her columns, followed her on Twitter (there are few reasons for hanging out on Twitter, but Roxane is one of them), and became enamored of her voice and her personal politics in Bad Feminist, I turned back to An Unt ...more
"Once upon a time, in a far away land, I was kidnapped by a band of fearless yet terrified young men ... They held me captive for thirteen days. They wanted to break me."
It is a great opening, told like a tragic fairytale by the victim but one that sadly the story does not get anywhere near the early promise. Haitian - American Mireille, a Miami lawyer is visiting her parents with her husband, Michael, and baby son, Christophe when she is kidnapped at gunpoint just outside her fathers mansion. M ...more
It is a great opening, told like a tragic fairytale by the victim but one that sadly the story does not get anywhere near the early promise. Haitian - American Mireille, a Miami lawyer is visiting her parents with her husband, Michael, and baby son, Christophe when she is kidnapped at gunpoint just outside her fathers mansion. M ...more
I am breathless...this may well be the best book I'll read it 2014. I know it is the best thus far. Anyone who reads my reviews knows that in order to rate 5 stars from me, I have to become one of the characters. Well I became Mireille. I am not Haitian, I am not black, I have never been kidnapped, never raped but Roxane Gay made me feel that I was all of these things. I blew through this book in less than 12 hours...the last time I remember that I did this was when I read The Kite Runner in 200
...more
Jul 16, 2014
Carol
rated it
really liked it
Recommended to Carol by:
Susan W.
Shelves:
contemporary,
read-2014
This chilling story begins with a vicious and unexpected attack by heavily armed men resulting in the kidnapping of a young mother, the daughter of one of Haiti's richest men, and when her (SOB) father refuses to negotiate her ransom, she endures 13 long torturous days of starvation and barbarous sexual abuse by multiple men and a major up-hill battle to come to terms with her life afterward.
Not an easy read by any means due to the descriptive brutality and violence, but a suspenseful tale of co
...more
WHAT A MOTHERFUCKING MASTERPIECE. Totally devastating. I can't even with this book. I was already in love with Gay's prolific oeuvre of short fiction and essays and as an editor she's actually published a couple stories of mine, but this was a special experience. I want everyone in the world who can bear it to read this absolutely stunning, horrifying, unforgettable fairy tale.
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Operation Book Club: BOOK 31: An Untamed State | 5 | 7 | Feb 10, 2017 02:09PM | |
2017 Reading Chal...:
An Untamed State
|
21 | 166 | Jan 31, 2017 01:42PM | |
| Literary Fiction ...: Discussion: An Untamed State | 276 | 239 | Mar 27, 2016 10:37PM |
Roxane Gay’s writing has appeared in Best American Short Stories 2012, Best Sex Writing 2012, Oxford American, American Short Fiction, West Branch, Virginia Quarterly Review, NOON, The New York Times Book Review, Bookforum, The Los Angeles Times, The Nation, The Rumpus, Salon, The Wall Street Journal’s Speakeasy culture blog, and many others. She is the co-editor of PANK and essays editor for The
...more
More about Roxane Gay...
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »
“I am not easy to love but I am well loved. I try to love well in return.”
—
23 likes
“Once upon a time, my life was a fairy tale and then I was stolen from everything I’ve ever loved. There was no happily ever after. After days of dying, I was dead.”
—
6 likes
More quotes…
Mar 23, 2016 12:16PM
By time I was done I was emotionally wrecked yet hopeful.
Merci Roxanne.
Jun 02, 2016 09:00AM