Physics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for active researchers, academics and students of physics. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

A heatsink can be stuck on your CPU to cool it down. That heatsink feels cold when the system is not turned on. However when the CPU is turned on the heatsink is extremely hot. Isn't that contradictory to a certain extent? I expect a heatsink to always be cold and to have the air blowing system turned on for convection purposes.

Could someone explain what is wrong in the way I see things?

share|cite|improve this question
up vote 8 down vote accepted

"I expect a heatsink to always be cold"

The purpose of the heat sink is to transfer heat. The rate of heat transfer depends in a complicated way on (a) the temperature difference between heat sink and air, (b) the exposed surface area, and (c) the air speed.

The heat sink is at its most effective if it is at the same temperature as the CPU. This is because this gives the maximum temperature difference between heat sink and air. This is why heat sinks are often made of copper: copper conducts heat well.

Let us suppose that the CPU is producing heat $Q$ (Watts) and that the heat sink transfer heat at a rate linear with the temperature difference:

$$ Q = K_\text{eff} (T_\text{CPU} - T_\text{air})$$

where $K_\text{eff}$ is the effective heat transfer coefficient. Solving for the CPU temperature:

$$ T_\text{CPU} = T_\text{air} + Q / K_\text{eff}$$

So, the CPU temperature is lowest when $K_\text{eff}$ is highest and $K_\text{eff}$ is highest when the heat sink, due it to having high thermal conductivity, is at nearly the same temperature as the CPU.

share|cite|improve this answer
    
So the purpose of metal of the heatsink itself is not to cool down the CPU but rather to be able to transfer it. While the purpose of the built-in fan is to cool down the CPU. Did I understand correctly what you meant? – trilolil 9 hours ago
    
@trilolil Yes, that's it. Without the air flow, there would be no place for the heat to go. – John1024 9 hours ago
4  
@trilolil The purpose of the heatsink is to touch lots of air, because when a hot thing touches a cold thing the cold thing gets hotter and the hot thing gets colder. The purpose of the fan is to blow the hot air out of the way after the heatsink heats it up, and replace it with cold air, because if the heatsink was only touching hot air it wouldn't be able to cool down very well. – immibis 4 hours ago
1  
@Aron The usual model for an ideal heat sink is that, while convective heat transfer is finite, the heat sink itself has infinite conductivity. This is part of the concept of "fin efficiency," as discussed here or here for example. If the heat sink has infinite conductivity, then it is at the same temperature as the CPU. Any reduction in the thermal conductivity reduces the overall heat transfer and makes the heat sink less effective. – John1024 4 hours ago
1  
@trilolil You can contrast it with what happens if you have a CPU without a heatsink - the CPU doesn't touch very much air because it's small, so it doesn't heat up the air very much, so it doesn't cool down very much. Also because it's smaller it heats up and cools down quickly, you don't want that because you want to have time to turn it off before it melts. – immibis 2 hours ago

In general, a heatsink should feel hot, if it's doing its job right. If it feels hot, that means it's transferring energy to your hand, which means it's transferring energy away from the CPU. Conversely if it felt cool, it'd be heating up the CPU.

This also holds for other cooling things. The cooling coils on a fridge or an old A/C should feel hot for the same reason: the heat you're taking away has to be dumped somewhere.

share|cite|improve this answer

A heat sink really shouldn't be hot (although it is a relative term, of course) at all. At higher temperature than ambient air certainly but not hot.

When a heat sink is in intimate contact with a source of heat, like a CPU, heat is transferred in accordance with Newton's Cooling Law:

$$\frac{\mathrm dQ}{\mathrm dt}=uA(T_\textrm{CPU}-T_\textrm{Sink})$$

Where $u$ is a heat transfer coefficient (CPU to sink) and $A$ is the area of contact between the CPU and the heat sink.

Note that $\frac{\mathrm dQ}{\mathrm dt}$ is the heat carried off from the CPU per unit of time.

Higher values of $T_\textrm{Sink}$, as the basic formula shows, actually decrease $\frac{\mathrm dQ}{\mathrm dt}$, which becomes effectively zero when $T_\textrm{CPU}-T_\textrm{Sink}=0$.

To prevent this from happening, the heat sink itself has to transfer accumulated heat, usually to the surrounding air, in which case another heat transfer equation comes into play:

$$\frac{\mathrm dQ}{\mathrm dt}=hA_\textrm{Sink}(T_\textrm{Sink}-T_\textrm{air})$$

Where $h$ is the convection heat transfer coefficient (sink to air) and $A_\textrm{Sink}$ the sink's surface area exposed to the air. $h$ is very dependent on speed or airflow which explains why forced air circulation (fan assisted ventilation) is often used.

In steady state ($T_\textrm {CPU}\approx \text{Constant}$), we have, with $\dot{Q}_\textrm{CPU}$ power generated by the CPU:

$$\dot{Q}_\textrm{CPU}=(T_\textrm{CPU}-T_\textrm{air})\left[\frac{1}{uA}+\frac{1}{hA_\textrm{sink}}\right]=(T_{CPU}-T_\textrm{air})\frac{1}{K}$$

Or:

$$T_\textrm{CPU}=T_\textrm{air}+K\dot{Q}_\textrm{CPU}$$

With:

$$K=\frac{uhAA_\textrm{Sink}}{hA_\textrm{Sink}+uA}$$

The influence of the various factors on $T_\textrm{CPU}$ can be readily appreciated.

Ingenious ways of increasing both $h$ (apart from forced circulation) and $A_\textrm{sink}$ to lower $T_\textrm{CPU}$ have been used like cooling fins or this design (ST-HT4 CPU Cooler Riser):

ST-HT4 CPU Cooler Riser

The highly heat conductive copper bands mostly release the heat from the U-bends.

share|cite|improve this answer
2  
I think you may want to reword the part where you say a heat sink shouldn't be hot. Yes, it should. An ideal heat sink is the same temperature as the thing it's cooling. – DanielSank 1 hour ago
    
Those 'copper bands' aren't solid copper; they're almost certainly heat pipes, which are significantly better heat conductors. That device won't improve cooling performance; it simply allows you to shift the cooler further from the CPU without a massive reduction in performance. – Someone Somewhere 6 mins ago

That nice image of a cooler riser looks as though the four copper U's are heat pipes; they have effective thermal conductivity far better than copper. Look up "heat pipes" for more info. They're worth knowing about.

Regards,

-- nb --

share|cite|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.