Editor rating: 7 / 10
James Reimer –– Very interesting deep-sea work combining basic biodiversity studies with ecology, with important implications for competition and populations in these understudied ecosystems. Editor rating: 8 / 10
Patricia Gandini –– An important long term study that show how populations change to different conditions and how to sample this variations, an important tool to conserve and protect right whales Section Editor rating: 7 / 10
James Reimer –– eDNA is an "exploding" field of study, and basic field methodology and analyses as in this paper are needed. Section Editor rating: 8 / 10
James Reimer –– Nice work examining variation in coral mucous production across days and seasons. Editor rating: 7 / 10
Per Palsboll –– The work informs people with an in the Arctic Ocean and climate change Editor rating: 7 / 10
Hauke Smidt –– Valuable contribution to the field of shrimp microbiota research Section Editor rating: 8 / 10
James Reimer –– Examination of an under-studied group of annelids with molecular phylogeny that proposes a clear way forward to resolve their taxonomy. Editor rating: 7 / 10
Anastazia Banaszak –– This publication provides basic but important evidence on the distribution of three species that have similar morphologies and are commonly misidentified. Editor rating: 7 / 10
Carlos Conte-Junior –– This article is relevant in the area of the fish consumer. There are few studies about the nutritional value of different fishes with the potential to produce in the word. Editor rating: 7 / 10
Albert Gabric –– The work on coralline responses to CC impacts such as acidification is weighted towards tropical ecosystems. This paper provides a useful counterbalance in the literature and as Dr Buscher has noted provides a window on the future of all coralline ecoystems. Discussing these articles



