Your people have been displaced by war, and have wandered for many months looking for a new home. Yesterday, you came across something truly marvelous. You are camped at the edge of a huge ravine, some two miles across and a thousand feet deep. At the bottom of the ravine runs a strait connecting two seas. Suspended magically in the midst of the ravine is a floating island, the top of which is level with the precipice upon which you stand, about a quarter mile away.

Your mission is to build a bridge from your location to that island, using the minimum amount of technology possible. Or in other words... how does one build a bridge when one has access neither to the ground below, nor the opposite side? Is there a way?

share|improve this question
    
Depends on how wide the gap is. How wide is the gap? – AlexP 11 hours ago
    
@AlexP Two miles, as per the question text – kingledion 10 hours ago
2  
@kingledion: Two miles is the width of the ravine. In the middle of the ravine is an island. The bridge needs to span the gap from the ravine edge to the island, not the entire width of the ravine. How wide is the gap between the edge of the ravine and the island? – AlexP 9 hours ago
    
Totally my bad! I have edited the question to add how far to the island. Thank you for pointing that out! – Arandur 8 hours ago
1  
I think you might need a combination of improbably powerful siege weaponry, extremely lucky shot with a big harpoon, insane amounts of insanely thick rope (particularly insane amounts for displaced refugees), extremely brave folks to climb up or shimmy along it, and maybe access to the coast and ships to sail to beneath the island. Hang gliders are technologically simple, but require a fair amount of scientific understanding to even conceive - and they require practice to use! So, just use giant tame birds. : ) – Grimm The Opiner 2 hours ago
up vote 3 down vote accepted

Hmmm, you've got problems. From the question text I'm assuming the island is at the halfway point and is ~1 mile across, so the bridge only has to be .5 miles long. I'm also assuming they don't have access to magic. If these assumptions are incorrect please clarify in the OP.

If they lack time and nearby resources they're screwed. If they have both:

One possibility is not building a "bridge" per-se, but rather extending a pole out to the island. Once they get one pole across it becomes easier to shuttle people along with, say, a basket and rope.

Now getting a half mile long pole across the ravine is no easy feat. If it's made of wood it's weight will make it bend down below the islands edge, so it will have to start at an upward angle or use some magic material that won't bend. It also can't be one piece, so these refugees will need to have the ability to make perfect connections between poles.

On second thought, a better idea: build a ballistia with a string attached to the bolt. Shoot the island. Now you have a rope extending across and you can either make a rope bridge or pull people back and forth in a basket. The first people to cross will have to crawl along the rope, so that will be dangerous, but also exciting if this is for a story.

Edit: So the longest range you can get on a ballista is ~800 meters. This isn't accounting for pulling along a bunch of rope capable of holding a man's weight. Don't wanna calculate that, so I'm just gonna halve it and say 400 meters (magic elven rope would of course help here). This is well short of .5 miles, so either the gap would have to be smaller, the ballista better, or they would have to build/find a higher place to fire from. For realism I would go for a combination of 1 and 3, but all would help.

share|improve this answer
    
I have edited the question to reflect the actual distance to the island, but in practice that distance will be determined by what it's possible to bridge! Your answer helps a lot in figuring that it; thank you. – Arandur 8 hours ago
2  
@Arandur maybe you could include that in the question -- "what's the greatest distance away the island could be that makes it possible to bridge?" – Pyritie 2 hours ago
    
You don't need rope capable of supporting a man's weight. You just need rope capable of supporting a slightly thicker bit of rope - maybe double width on a pulley. . (Or course, 400m of anything is going to have a fairly impressive weight to it). – Sobrique 1 hour ago

Suspended magically in the midst of the ravine is a floating island, the top of which is level with the precipice upon which you stand, about a quarter mile away.

Ok, part of the locally available resources is something that allows magic suspension of huge static loads.

Use the same magic to make pontoons on which to construct the bridge.

share|improve this answer
1  
That requires 4 or 5 PhD, maybe more ;-) – coredump 55 mins ago

2 miles for a group of poor refugees? We can barely do that with every bit of materials engineering and construction know-how that we have in the year 2017. The largest suspension bridge in the world is that size, and it took 10 years and $3.6 billion to build it.

Without magic or handwaving, it can't be done in the scenario you present.

share|improve this answer
1  
Building a suspension bridge also requires access to both ends of the span to build the towers, and what does the tower do to the weight & balance of the magic island? Your best bet would be to build hang gliders, wait for a day when there's a lot of ridge lift, and sail across. Or perhaps hot-air balloons: you could eventually carry a cable across to eliminate the chance of them drifting away. – jamesqf 8 hours ago
2  
The question doesn't talk about crossing the entire gap - it describes going a quarter mile to the island. – Zxyrra 6 hours ago
    
@jamesqf You should make that an answer. – Zxyrra 6 hours ago
    
A suspension bridge requires both 'ends' - a cantilever just needs one in the middle. Which might be viable if you're prepared to build a bridge twice the length (or with just a mahoosive counterweight in lieu of a span) so doubling the size of the problem, basically, but not actually complicated in a science sense - rather more so in an engineering sense though. (But that's going to be the case on any long bridge) – Sobrique 1 hour ago

Well, there's a way - bridging vehicles exist, and make bridges from 'one side':

Youtube video of a 'real' one'

And a LEGO one

It's pretty low tech - but moderately high engineering, as you need a folding span half the 'width' of your bridge, and a rather significant 'ballast' to stop toppling. On a quarter-mile span, that's going to be a rather impressive sort of a challenge - you'll need a bridge 'doodad' that's 2 lots of 200m, which isn't a trivial sort of a number. And enough 'counterbalance' on the bridging vehicle - you'd probably need a ballast on a lever, sort of similar to what you'd get on a gantry crane

But in a world where there's magic, it may be altogether more doable.

The bonus here is that you could - potentially - recover your bridge, and have a pretty secure fortress....

share|improve this answer
    
The word you're probably looking for is cantilever. – Separatrix 1 hour ago

The answer lies in the question's premise.

The premise of your question suggests there is technology available in this world: the technology which allows the floating island to exist.

Now consider this. The floating island is essentially a floating air pontoon. Instead of a water pontoon. The air pontoon floats in air. Now imaging stringing together a chain of similar but smaller air pontoons to form the bases of the bridge. Then lower an attaching walkway between each pontoon in the chain. Now you have a floating air pontoon bridge as requested.

share|improve this answer

A quarter mile is not that bad, 700 meter ziplines exist. The longest footbridge span I know of is the Kusma-Gyadi Bridge in Nepal which spans ~300 meters. The hardest thing is getting the first piece of cordage across the span, a balloon with the lightest cordage possible would be your best bet, although depending on the span a catapult might work. Then you use that to pull heavier cordage across. The biggest for you is getting a person on the other side to tie toe cordage to something, that's why I said a hot air balloon might be necessary.

Nepal is full of rope and cable bridges if you want to see how they make them. Many spans are just crossed by a single rope or cable and they hang from a basket and hand-walk along it, Although their classic three rope foot bridge is probably the best for constant traffic.

enter image description here

share|improve this answer
    
You haven't really covered how this is done with access to only one side. – Grimm The Opiner 2 hours ago
    
Ballistae? Fire a cable on a harpoon? – Sobrique 1 hour ago
    
@Sobrique that is actually a viable way to do this. – Doomed Mind 39 mins ago

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.