Indexing event parameters corrupting data

Question

If I index a parameter or any number of parameters, some of the return values get swapped and/or corrupted.. I am not sure if any one else has ever seen this behavior before.

Non-indexed Event:

event ReportedFraud(
        uint256 fraudID,
        address bank,
        string accountNumber,
        string routingNumber,
        uint256 amount,
        uint256 fromID,
        uint256 time
    );

Correct Values Returned:

accountNumber: "123"
amount: "1"
bank: "0x10674178eAf18F06785b76fF689dcfa5175b098C"
fraudID: "1"
fromID: "0"
routingNumber: "456"
time: "1551236055"

Indexed Event:

event ReportedFraud(
    uint256 indexed fraudID,
    address bank,
    string accountNumber,
    string routingNumber,
    uint256 indexed amount,
    uint256 indexed fromID,
    uint256 time
);

Corrupted/Swapped Values Returned:

accountNumber: "123"
amount: "1"
bank: "0x10674178eAf18F06785b76fF689dcfa5175b098C"
fraudID: "51119459429513360686315515087327623333677688524449823590986145582251952174345"
fromID: "50000"
routingNumber: "456"
time: "1551236055"

Here is the web3js code calling the event from the blockchain.

fraudListen = () => {
  this.KYCinstance.events.ReportedFraud({ fromBlock:0 }, 
    (error, event) => {
      if (error) {
        console.log(error);
      }
      else {
        values = event.returnValues;

        var fraudID = document.createTextNode("Fraud ID: " + values.fraudID);
        var bank = document.createTextNode("Bank: " + values.bank);
        var accountNumber = document.createTextNode("Account Number: " + values.accountNumber);
        var routingNumber = document.createTextNode("Routing Number: " + values.routingNumber);
        var amount = document.createTextNode("Amount: " + values.amount);
        var fromID = document.createTextNode("From_ID: " + values.fromID)
        var time = document.createTextNode("Time: " + utils.timeConverter(values.fromID));

        var elements = [fraudID, bank, accountNumber, routingNumber, amount, fromID, time];

        fraudEvents = document.getElementById("fraudEvents");
        var divItem = document.createElement('div');
        divItem.setAttribute('class', "fraudEvent")

        for (var i = 0; i < elements.length; i++) {
          var listItem = document.createElement('ul');
          listItem.appendChild(elements[i]);
          divItem.appendChild(listItem);
        }

        fraudEvents.insertBefore(divItem, fraudEvents.firstChild);
        var linebreak = document.createElement('br');
        fraudEvents.insertBefore(linebreak, divItem);
      }
    });

  console.log('now listening for events');
}