David's Reviews > The Giving Tree

The Giving Tree by Shel Silverstein
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3073544
's review
Aug 11, 2011

liked it
bookshelves: low-calorie, brat-lit

HEY, KIDS AND SHEL SILVERSTEIN FANS! COME OVER HERE AND READ THIS!

Okay, this some motherfuckin' fucked-up shit right here. The Giving Tree is the straight-up wack story of how this selfish little ass-faced prick kicks it with this full-on saintly tree. Ever'thin' fine for a while, y'all, with the lil' prick all gettin' up in there an' sayin' to the tree, "Yeah, you know you mah bitch," but then all of a sudden, this jumped-up prick go through puberty, get his chia on or some such shit, and so he's off screwin' the skank-ass bitches on the block all damn day and can't spare one motherfuckin' minute for this poor old tree who waitin' for him and lookin' all motherfuckin' sad an' droopy an' shit. So this little punk-ass bitch come up on the tree -- this is a motherfuckin' tree, hear? -- and ask her ['cuz she a sexy-ass lady-tree] fo' some g's. Well, the tree is all, like, "I ain't got no cash, bitch. What part o' me say ATM on it? Mmm-hmmm. I thought so..." And she shoulda held up there, but -- no -- this tree gets all fuckin' benevolent and be, like, "Well, I got mad apples you can go hustle on the streets." So this ass-faced prick just, like, boosts all these goddamn apples an' leaves this tree with, like, its weave all out an' shit. So next, after workin' the streets wit his crew, little bitch boy come back, lookin' all older an' jacked-up, and ask the motherfuckin' tree for a goddamn crib. So the tree like, "Hol' up. Do you even fuckin' see Coldwell Banker all up an' down in here? I think not." But then, being all kindly an' shit, the tree is, like, "But I got mad branches..." And what? She motherfuckin' takes it up back again fo' this fool. Later, another goddamn time, punk-ass bitch come back, lookin' all old an' saggy and wack now, and he like, "Bitch, what you got fo' me now?" "Awww, hell naw," tree says, but then she start gettin' all soft an' shit again an' say, "Why don' you cut down my trunk or some such shit and go 'head and whittle a pimped-out yacht, full-on Hamptons-style?" He, like, "Yeah, I thought so, bitch." And then -- guess the fuck what? -- little shriveled-up, played-out mack come on back wit his ass all hemorrhoided-up an' shit. He look straight-up nasty and old. Tree is, like, "I know you ain't come t'ask me. All's I got is a motherfuckin' stump, you ass-faced motherfucker. How you gon' come back at me like that?" This punk-ass bitch is all drooling and jacked-up and just wanna sit the hell down. What do the motherfuckin' tree do? She say, "Hell no! You motherfuckin' fucked-up fucker, get yo' motherfuckin' ass face out o' here fo' I cut you up good: give you some stank-ass mad tree fungus, motherfucker!" The motherfuckin' end, motherfuckers.

Okay, so that's not really the way The Giving Tree ends, but maybe it's the way it should. Some time ago, my ex-girlfriend and, afterward, long-time co-dependent friend gave me The Giving Tree as part of my birthday gift. I loved it, but I hated it, too, because I felt so bad for the tree who is endlessly shat upon by this worthless "Boy"--as he is always known, regardless of age; I longed to console the tree and, maybe a little, to condemn this book as yet another emotionally-scarring "children's" entertainment in the manner of Old Yeller. Don't give me any shit about learning valuable lessons. The only lesson I learned was that human beings are nothing but steaming piles of corn-freckled feces, and that I wanted to found a not-for-profit shelter for unloved trees and rabid dogs and any other nonhuman thing, living or not, which was either unwanted or despised.

Having said all this -- and although I don't approve of the treatment of the giving tree -- this book is very moving and very delicate. The delicacy is somewhat counteracted when the reader turns over the book and sees the author photograph of a thoroughly evil-looking Shel Silverstein. He looks like the sort of person who would burn down whole forests of rare giving trees just for kicks. Picture Othello just before he strangles Desdemona.

If you -- and, yes, I'm talking to you personally -- are not moved by the plight of the tree after reading this book, then perhaps it's time to go an' check yo'self: are you the givin' tree or are you the motherfuckin' takin' tree? Or are you the sneak-out-in-the-middle-of-the-night-an'-steal-all-my-shit tree?
607 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Giving Tree.
Sign In »

Comments (showing 1-50 of 436) (436 new)


message 1: by David (last edited Dec 04, 2010 09:40AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

David This review, twice deleted by Goodreads and twice deleted by me, has been reinstated -- to the delight of some and, no doubt, the profound dismay of many more -- due to the preservationist instincts of Kim D., who knows my volatility and capriciousness all too well.

If you find this review obnoxious, offensive, tiresome, stupid, and/or a symptom or cause of the decline of Western Civilization, then I invite you to point your blame-designating fingers her way. Her house is located somewhere in the northeastern United States, for those desirous of assembling a torch-wielding mob to pay her a visit and to learn her up real good 'bout moral'ty and good taste and innernit etiquette.

Also, if you hate this review, you are stupid and probably a retard, but I have nothing against stupidity or retardation because I'm not a hurtful bigot like you.


message 2: by Eh?Eh! (new)

Eh?Eh! ...this is like going up to the attic, flicking away a dead mouse, and finding that thing that reminds you of hours in the family van with all the "I'm not touching you, moooooom!" and stabbing for the last piece of chicken. Thanks for the memories.


Joshua Nomen-Mutatio Wasn't this like three times as long before?? Or do I misremember?


Mariel You giveth and you taketh away... snd giveth again.


David MyFleshSingsOut wrote: "Wasn't this like three times as long before?? Or do I misremember?"

There was a different original version (once upon a time) with additional personal information, which I later thought better of publicly revealing, but the beginning parody is fully intact.


message 6: by Manny (new)

Manny I'm voting before it's back to the vaults for another generation.

By the way, why was this fine review deleted? I still don't quite understand.


message 7: by Jessica (last edited Dec 04, 2010 01:26PM) (new)

Jessica this must be the 3rd or 4th? time I've voted for this damn review.

I can remember in my early days on GR, coming across this review and laughing out loud, what is this shit?
and then reading it to my son, who I knew was old enough to be able to handle the obscenity-laden rapper-like ripping voice of it and we both agreed, this was some funny shit and this Kowalski-guy was one brilliant bastard.


message 8: by Jessica (new)

Jessica I also remember, in the early days, that it got flagged and removed and some of us got very vocal (the other Jessica was one, can't recall the rest) about censorship on our beloved goodreads.

So...here it is again.
am getting all nostalgic now
;-)


message 9: by Ademption (new)

Ademption I love voting for this review.


message 10: by Michael (new)

Michael Ah, reveries of those bygone days when I read this review before, except I didn't, because I'm not old as dirt like you Olden-Agers.

Hilarious review, David. And yes, this book is beyond fucked up.


message 11: by Jessica (new)

Jessica ha yeah, I feel old as dirt...

;-)


Malbadeen The fact that this book is so immensely popular might speak, at least a little, to people not being as horrible as you'd like to believe they are.
I mean, don't get me wrong. I don't really care for the book and buying the book is just cutting down more of those damn trees anyway but I'm just saying, come on David - - - give the world a hug every now and again.


message 13: by Jessica (new)

Jessica but the message of the book is a strange one...I remember when my son got it as a gift from an uncle...I read it to him, I loved the pictures...but what about this poor long-suffering tree? and this selfish boy?


Joshua Nomen-Mutatio Yeah, sometimes the world will give you a little reacharound action while its, ya know, doin' it bidness.


Malbadeen Jessica - agreed!

David - give your Uncle World a hug.


Michelle It's back! Hello, old friend.


message 17: by Lisa (new) - rated it 1 star

Lisa Vegan David, Have you read The Taking Tree: A Selfish Parody?


message 18: by Kim (new)

Kim Yep! It's my fault! I take full on motherfuckin' credit, dudes...

Yay, David!


David Lisa wrote: "David, Have you read The Taking Tree: A Selfish Parody?"

Yep. I even have a review up for it.


message 20: by Lisa (new) - rated it 1 star

Lisa Vegan David wrote: "Lisa wrote: "David, Have you read The Taking Tree: A Selfish Parody?"

Yep. I even have a review up for it."


Ah, me too. I loved it. Great fun.


message 21: by Jen (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jen Kim, you are my giving tree right now. This just made my month. Really.

I've copied and pasted this to myself; now there will be a second back-up. I'm sure I'm not the only one.


message 22: by RandomAnthony (new)

RandomAnthony I'm telling. Mom! David's talking bad about The Giving Tree again!


message 23: by Kim (new)

Kim Yeah, where is Charissa these days? :)


Books Ring Mah Bell Like Lazarus, it returns. Praise GAWD!
:)


message 25: by Dave (new)

Dave Russell I wish there were a way to get this on Seth's update feed, but I doubt he has any friends left who would "like" this.


message 26: by David (last edited Dec 06, 2010 08:08PM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

David I think that's the only reason I put this review back up. I knew that there was the possibility that that jackass Seth would stumble upon it and start frothing in curmudgeonly rage.


Weinz I've lost count how many times I've voted for this review over the years. It is like that damn Christmas toffee... giddy as a school girl every time it is time for it to come back.


The Crimson Fucker I voted for this review cuz david asked me to vote for all of his reviews!


Mariel The fro loves this too. <3


♥Xeni♥ Okay, at first I was just appalled at the language! And then while reading I noticed how the language was definitely a must for your review of the book. It's been ages since I read the book, and I don't remember much of it anyway, but if I read it again now, I'd probably write something similar to this (albeit a bit more cleaned up).

Thanks for the honest review.

P.S. After reading all the comments on this, I'm surprised that I haven't seen this review before! Still, a part of me is glad that I had a chance to read this review before it probably gets deleted again.


Christa David wrote: "This review, twice deleted by Goodreads and twice deleted by me, has been reinstated -- to the delight of some and, no doubt, the profound dismay of many more -- due to the preservationist instinct..."


Its not the review I find "obnoxious, offensive, tiresome, stupid, and/or a symptom or cause of the decline of Western Civilization". Just you. Get a life.


Weinz Says the woman who lists Danielle Steele as a favorite author.

:) good reads is full of all kinds. That is what makes it great.


Michelle ^^^^
Michelle, high five.

Yes, all kinds, and they usually come out to play on David's Giving Tree review thread. I wonder when the crazy chick with the rose avatar will figure out the review is back.


message 34: by [deleted user] (new)

Elizabeth wrote: "Doesn't give you a feeling that all is right with the world? The Giving Tree review + Haters = Goodreads. "

it's a time when the golden agers and the bronze agers can join together as one against the trolls. it's really quite special.


message 36: by David (last edited Dec 18, 2010 03:09AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

David Christa wrote: "Get a life."

Is reading Fannie Flagg 'a life'?

If so, I'm definitely not pro-life.


message 37: by Cynthia (new)

Cynthia I feel like holding hands and singing that song from The Grinch Stole Christmas, welcome Christmas, Christmas time...


David karen sent me a great goth/ethereal xmas mix that included this haunting Love Spirals Downward version of the 'Welcome, Christmas' song from the Grinch:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Odoh38...

(Thanks, karen!)


Michelle This was all I could find:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-ibc_5...

It looks (and sounds) terrible.


Joshua Nomen-Mutatio Hannah do you support all forms of fascism or just the ones that cotton to your misguided, prudish concerns?


Weinz Michelle likes message 46


David I think she digs me. I hope she's not twelve.


message 44: by JSou (last edited Jan 04, 2011 08:12PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

JSou Photobucket

EDIT: Michelle beat me to it! : )


Weinz Still counts! I like the shoe better. We could have an entire "ode to DK" ensemble.


message 46: by Eh?Eh! (new)

Eh?Eh! Michelle wrote: "We could have an entire "ode to DK" ensemble."

You've got the undies, the shoes, and the ironic trucker hat.




Weinz Sounds like a complete outfit to me!


message 48: by Ashley (new)

Ashley Black This is q very heart warming story so if you don't like it and think that way about it then don't comment about it!!!! This is a place to comment good things about it!!!!!!


message 49: by Ashley (new)

Ashley Black I do agree though that the boy is VERY selfish but still give the book a break and the guy that wrote it looks very scary!!!!!


Michelle No, this is not q place to only comment good things about books. This is q place to express your opinions (good or bad) on books.


« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
back to top