User Experience Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for user experience researchers and experts. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

What is the significance of start-up sound of a system, like mobile phones, operating systems etc.?

What aspect of user experience it enhances?

share|improve this question
6  
What is the significance of saying "hello" to people? What aspect of social experience does it enhance? – Lightness Races in Orbit 20 hours ago
10  
It serves as a demonstration of just how out-of-touch certain developers are with the desires of some of their users. It's one reason (sound-producing websites are the other) why I've remove speakers from all my computers. – jamesqf 18 hours ago
1  
@jamesqf time to meet Firefox, it can disable sounds globally – Sarge Borsch 16 hours ago
    
I thought this was going to be about real-world systems. Generators, vehicles, power tools, that kind of thing. There, the startup sound greatly affects the ability of a dealer to sell. Quiet engines and noisy software should never be trusted with anything important. – Dan Ross 9 hours ago

11 Answers 11

My understanding was that it came from a time when startup could take a while, during which the user's attention would be elsewhere and therefore worth notifying them when the computer was ready for use.

Something similar was mentioned in answer to another question:

The Operating System took so long to start up that the chime notified people that it was worth bothering to come back to the computer from, e.g., making a coffee. (Should we use a sound/jingle when users arrive on our site or open our app?)

According to comments made by Microsoft to Mashable, the startup sound was removed in Windows 10 because there's no need to draw attention to startup:

When we modernized the soundscape of Windows, we intentionally quieted the system. Using Windows 10, you will only hear sounds for things that matter to you. We removed the startup sound because startup is not an interesting event on a modern device. Picking up and using a device should be about you, not announcing the device's existence.

share|improve this answer
12  
Also, the startup sounds is used to assure you that the sound hardware is installed properly and working. Puppy Linux uses a puppy bark to let you know that ALSA is working correctly. – Ismael Miguel 21 hours ago
    
TOAD uses a croak (or "ribbit" in their docs) to indicate the program has loaded. – noonand 21 hours ago
1  
@Alvaro Possibly that is (or will be in a second or two) to pull the battery or plug from the device. – chepner 21 hours ago
50  
In case of Macs, it can also serve the function to announce to a whole silent library "hey, I have a Mac". – Andrea Lazzarotto 20 hours ago
2  
AFAIK, on every 68k- an PPC-Mac, the startup sound indicated that the machine passed the POST (Power-On Self Test, or whatever you want to call it). I'm not sure if that carried over to the x86 architecture. Also, with that sound, the user has quick feedback that the power button/switch has been operated correctly, before any CRT hat a chance to get a picture on the screen. The latter is of course not really an issue anymore. – Feuermurmel 14 hours ago

Part of it is iconic branding, much like putting the logo on the boot screen. I can still remember the startup sound from windows xp and playstation one.

share|improve this answer

To give auditory feedback to the user that the system has started loading.

Here are 3 reasons why:

  1. Prevent users from hitting the power button multiple times.

    Users should not wonder whether the system is starting or not. If there was no starting sound how would users know that the system has successfully started? They might press the power button a couple of times not knowing that the system is already starting which can cause loss of information and a lot of headaches;

  2. Display not working during repairs

    During hardware repairs when technicians haven't connected display or the display is not working and cannot get visual feedback. In this situation auditory feedback comes in very handy.


Update:

  1. Cue for visually impaired (@Devin answer)

    Visually impaired people rely on hearing and touching when trying to understand the environment around them. If there are no auditory(sound) or haptic(touch/vibration) cues they won't know what is happening with the device.

share|improve this answer
2  
My recollection is that it was a Mac thing initially - Mac's have always gone "Boing" when they fire up (which Windows copied). You could use it as part of fault finding to identify where things had gone wrong. – PhillipW 18 hours ago
1  
@PhillipW Earlier Macs (I had the SE FDHD) went "beep" when switched on, and "bong" once the startup was finished. My understanding is that this was because the "bong" audio didn't fit in ROM, so they put it in the System instead, where it was only available once the OS had loaded. Later systems put the bong in ROM and played it as soon as power was applied (and also had the "car crash" and "chimes of death" sounds for startup diagnostics). – Wolfgang 15 hours ago
1  
@wolfgang No, that's wrong. I have a closet full of compact Macs. None of them "beep" and "bong", including the SE FDHD. There is a single chime when the Mac powers on and passes the power-on self-test. The "bong" chime is indeed in ROM, and not part of the system software on disk. All of the other diagnostic sounds are in ROM, too, including the car crash, chimes of death, etc., and thus they're all model-specific. The initial chime has been in ROM since the very first Macintosh. Now, the system software also has sounds installed, but they don't play automatically on startup. – Cody Gray 8 hours ago
    
@CodyGray I've just spent some time on YouTube, and all of the SEs I can find do the beep I remember (e.g. youtu.be/95nGY_o_FoY) but not the bong as the Finder is starting, which was a resource in the System file. It's entirely possible that this was not Apple standard, as the computer had at least two previous owners. My previous comment was based on my assumptions from the time, given that the other (newer) Macs I knew played an identical bong at a different time, but appears to be incorrect. – Wolfgang 6 hours ago
    
Yeah, that chime from the YouTube video is the sound that is in the SE ROM, and it makes that chime after power is applied and the power-on self-test is completed. Newer Macs have different sounds in their ROM, which sound more like a bong, but they are played at the same time. Wikipedia has a brief list of the startup chimes for different models, and there are probably various places online where you can hear them if you don't have your own Mac collection, like this YouTube video – Cody Gray 6 hours ago

Asides from old systems and their delay times at start, or branding considerations (both correct reasons), one reason that I might add is that it serves as a Sensory Cue.

This is true both for blind or impaired vision users, in which startup sound is of paramount importance (this sound is the only indication they have in order to know that the system is "ready to go") as well as "regular" users with no disabilities. In this regard, there are thousands of studies about sensory cues as start points that prepare the brain for a task.

Try to picture this (or even better, test if you have the means): simply think of yourself waiting for the system to start, then you hear the sound. Is your mood the same?

If you want, try doing this very simple experiment (we already did it!): simply call some people, maybe even your fellow co-workers or family, and film them from the point they press the ON button on a computer, until they hear the sound. 5-10 testers will be enough for this simple experiment. If your results are similar to ours, you'll see a very perceptible change on the testers. They will usually smile, or they will change their body position, or they will look more alert. Anyways, no matter the attitude they take, the important part is that most users (if not all) will react in some way

Note: New technologies will rely on aural(auditory)-haptic cues rather than only aural cues, so this answer is more related to desktop or laptop devices

share|improve this answer

Beeps during POST are there to help with troubleshooting. Think of it like debugging: if you can't tell why your script isn't working or where, it helps to have it echoing its status along the way in a very verbose manner so it becomes apparent where the issue is. It's like a ping.

POST does a lot of simple things very quickly to test itself (this is all in BIOS so it's actually the motherboard firmware testing itself, and associated components like processor and memory) like loading basic hardware drivers to talk with other components, and verifying its own hardware such as the speaker works with a quick beep.MIDI (Talking about the speaker on the motherboard itself here, not the auxiliary speakers you plug in to the back.)

So typically, the computer makes a "beep" only after it has tested and loaded the most basic-of-the-basics that make it possible for it to "beep". (i.e. indicates successful POST) Basically it is the response to your ping on the power button, "Hello?", "Yes, Hello! I have power and my basic hardware is functional."

So a post-POST beep is there to enhance the technician's experience, or the technical-user's.

Consider the example: You and I have just received the parts to build a new computer, so we unbox the motherboard to perform a benchtest to verify everything is functional first. We power on the system, and get no picture.

Here's a perfect example why those beeps are so important: if we get no beep, what could be wrong? 1) POST did not complete successfully, 2) Speaker hardware is damaged, 3) Major component missing (processor/memory not seated properly) 4) Manufacturer did not include BEEP after POST in firmware, so it still could have POSTed successfully and the issue really is the monitor, 5) cable, or 6) motherboard connector.

If we get one beep, that's easy: it's either the monitor or the cable (or the connector).

If we get more than one beep, that's also easy: obviously POST did not complete successfully, but now we can work out the issue (# of beeps = errorcode) quite easily with trivial research. Troubleshooting is fantastically difficult without verbosity.

After all this hardware stuff completes is where the OS takes over. While POST completes almost immediately, obviously OS takes a lot longer.

Hence, when BOOT has completed most OS's will play a "Welcome Sound" like the chimes on Windows XP or the Beatles' "A Day in the Life" ending used on the Mac.

This post-BOOT sound can be much higher quality and more detailed than the simple MIDI sounds of a motherboard speaker, so while this sound has been used for branding purposes as others have already mentioned, it's primary function is to indicate that it has finished booting. (As others' answers have already mentioned.)

Thus, the Welcome Sounds enhance the end-user's experience, for it indicates BOOT has completed and they can return from making coffee now.

Side Note: It depends on how old you are if you'll notice, that nowadays POST is obfuscated in favor of a manufacturer's logo, and it completes so quick on modern hardware you wouldn't see much anyway. The beep either happens so instantaneously (right after you press the power button) that you either don't notice it, or manufacturers have started disabling it by default. Both are options you can most probably turn back on in BIOS.

Edit: It's not even BIOS we use anymore, now it's called UEFI. I'm not even 30 yet and my old is showing.

share|improve this answer

Branding.

Of course there are other reasons to include it, like letting the user know the hardware is working, start up is finished and they can interact with the computer, etc. but it is an extremely powerful branding tool. It is familiar, it becomes expected, and if it's a good one, it can evoke strong feelings in us (see for instance http://gizmodo.com/end-of-an-era-goodbye-mac-startup-sound-1788383059 ). It reminds us of our relationship with the computer.

share|improve this answer

It is a notification that the software and hardware checks have passed (with no beep codes), and that the user is now able to access an operating system through a command interface shell or an associated GUI (Graphical User Interface) desktop.

share|improve this answer

Depends on what you mean by the startup, do you mean when you actually log in? Or do you mean when you turn the computer on, once you get to the login screen the noises made serve to do nothing at all and are just branding?

When you actually turn on the computer it can make a variety of noises most commonly heard are beeps, depending on the motherboard each beep be it single double triple etc.. or long drawn out "solid" pings so to speak are typically intended to alert the user to an issue such as a malfunction on the board its self or the failure of hardware; HDDs, GPUs, CPUs, unfortunately, more people are unaware of this than those that aren't which means these noises typically go ignored and if one happens to be an alert tone for a malfunction the issue only gets worse down the line.

share|improve this answer

At least for computers, beeps are a way to inform the user of problems if there is no (connection to the) screen.

Different mainboard brands have different beeps: Mainboard debug sounds so that a technician has a hint on where to start his search if the system is not booting.

share|improve this answer

There are different ways an OS uses to give feedback to the user aside from visual. In the case of desktop devices, sound is used to give feedback and communicate something happened or to call for the attention of the user.

As @MattObee states in his answer, a start-up sound tells the user that the system turned on and thus is responsive. Other sound notifications can be used when an error happened or some process finished. The same happens when the system is turned off.

In the case of Mobile devices the sound feedback can be substituted with haptic feedback.

share|improve this answer

If we include a Dial-up Internet connection as 'starting a system', then the dial up sounds are all actual line tones and are used to negotiate the exchange of information. The reason they are audible, as I understand it, is so that if the connection is not working an engineer (or someone with a manual) can figure out which stage of the connection is failing based on the tones and fix from there.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.