Mike Mullin's Reviews > Wonder
Wonder
by R.J. Palacio
by R.J. Palacio
Amazing. Absolutely amazing. Among the best novels I've ever read--note I didn't say best middle-grade novels. This story is so powerful, so beautifully told that it transcends genre. I recommend it for middle-grade students. I recommend it for teenagers. I recommend it for adults--even if you've never read a middle-grade novel, even if you've read and hated middle-grade novels, try this one.
A few months ago, after reading a string of YA novels that equated inner beauty with exterior (an infuriating and lazy trope that has infected YA like, well, vampirism), I spent a few fruitless moments raging at the universe, asking where was the brilliant fiction about ugly people. Normally the universe ignores my rants. In this case, however, the universe dropped WONDER into my lap. (Actually I checked it out from my local library. If the universe had literally dropped it into my lap, I imagine that would have hurt. The universe is nothing if not really, really tall. But having read the library copy, I'm going to buy two tomorrow. One for my wife's fourth-grade classroom, and one for me to keep and re-read. It's so good that I want Ms. Palacio to get paid twice.)
August Pullman was born with a facial deformity so severe that it and the necessary surgeries prevented him from attending school until the fifth grade. And so his first day at school isn't as one of a flock of terrified kindergarteners--instead, he becomes the chum in the shark tank of middle school. What follows is a beautiful, heart-breaking, terrifying, and funny tale about an extraordinary kid, bullying, and, ultimately, the wondrous power of kindness.
The writing is perfect for the story--simple yet lovely, with not an extra word or chapter to mar it. Last year I had a brief conversation with Bruce Coville, in which I argued that a young adult novel with five points-of-view likely wouldn't work or sell, and Bruce argued that I was wrong. Well, I was wrong. (Duh, I know, this was BRUCE FREAKING COVILLE--of course he knows far more about this topic than I!) Anyway, Palacio uses SIX POV characters to get her story across, and does it so seamlessly that there's never a moment where I wondered why she switched viewpoints, or wished she'd get back into Augie's head--although she does, wisely, both begin and end the novel in his perspective.
And Palacio doesn't stop transcending genre tropes there, either. There are parents in this book. Lovely, caring parents, of the sort you either had or wish you did. If you've read much YA or middle-grade fiction recently, you know how rare and therefore precious this is.
So, I know this is a random collection of fanboy raving, and I should really wait to hit Save until I've gone back and edited this review a little, but then you'd have to wait to find out how awesome WONDER is and START READING IT FOR YOURSELF! So I'll clean this up later and repost here and on my blog. In the meantime, why are you still reading this? You could be reading WONDER!
A few months ago, after reading a string of YA novels that equated inner beauty with exterior (an infuriating and lazy trope that has infected YA like, well, vampirism), I spent a few fruitless moments raging at the universe, asking where was the brilliant fiction about ugly people. Normally the universe ignores my rants. In this case, however, the universe dropped WONDER into my lap. (Actually I checked it out from my local library. If the universe had literally dropped it into my lap, I imagine that would have hurt. The universe is nothing if not really, really tall. But having read the library copy, I'm going to buy two tomorrow. One for my wife's fourth-grade classroom, and one for me to keep and re-read. It's so good that I want Ms. Palacio to get paid twice.)
August Pullman was born with a facial deformity so severe that it and the necessary surgeries prevented him from attending school until the fifth grade. And so his first day at school isn't as one of a flock of terrified kindergarteners--instead, he becomes the chum in the shark tank of middle school. What follows is a beautiful, heart-breaking, terrifying, and funny tale about an extraordinary kid, bullying, and, ultimately, the wondrous power of kindness.
The writing is perfect for the story--simple yet lovely, with not an extra word or chapter to mar it. Last year I had a brief conversation with Bruce Coville, in which I argued that a young adult novel with five points-of-view likely wouldn't work or sell, and Bruce argued that I was wrong. Well, I was wrong. (Duh, I know, this was BRUCE FREAKING COVILLE--of course he knows far more about this topic than I!) Anyway, Palacio uses SIX POV characters to get her story across, and does it so seamlessly that there's never a moment where I wondered why she switched viewpoints, or wished she'd get back into Augie's head--although she does, wisely, both begin and end the novel in his perspective.
And Palacio doesn't stop transcending genre tropes there, either. There are parents in this book. Lovely, caring parents, of the sort you either had or wish you did. If you've read much YA or middle-grade fiction recently, you know how rare and therefore precious this is.
So, I know this is a random collection of fanboy raving, and I should really wait to hit Save until I've gone back and edited this review a little, but then you'd have to wait to find out how awesome WONDER is and START READING IT FOR YOURSELF! So I'll clean this up later and repost here and on my blog. In the meantime, why are you still reading this? You could be reading WONDER!
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Wonder.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
| 03/15/2016 | marked as: | read | ||
Comments (showing 1-15 of 15) (15 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Claire
(new)
May 17, 2012 03:15PM
Thanks for the review of this heartwarming novel.I heartily recommend Wonder. Mike, as an author of middle school Eco mysteries, I too am upset by the shallow and often callous messages embedded in popular books for Tweens and teens. The natural world is filled with "magice" we don't need voodoo to divert kids from engaging in a meaning ful way with the wonder and beauty of the real world.
reply
|
flag
*
I don't mean to imply that I dislike books that contain magic or voodoo or even vampires--I love many of them. I just dislike the equating of internal and external beauty that happens in some YA.
I saw a review for this (in Horn Book?) and was a bit ambivalent; I usually like my books to be happy. I do agree that YA has long used appearance to equate with good and evil. It's not only lazy, but extremely unfair. I think I will give this one a go.
Bah, what does the Horn Book know? (I'm kidding!) All I can say is that I connected with WONDER at a deep, emotional level, found the writing suited the characters beautifully, and the book exploded several overused tropes of its genre. Triple win!
I'm glad you're kidding. I spend so much time and money on reading, that I use reviews to help guide me in discovering new authors. It's how I found you!
Cheralaine, I generally like my books to be happy also, but I didn't find Wonder to be unhappy. Sure, there were parts in which I was weeping & I'm not sure how I'll manage the read-aloud that I'm planning this year. All that said, Wonder had a hopefulness and a humanity that made it a pleasure to read. Several kids who had begun by bullying responded to Augie's humor and personality, cementing a friendship that I hadn't expected. (Yes, I'm the 4th grade teacher that Mike refers to. I also rated this book with 5 stars.)
I, too, loved Wonder for the reasons you gave in your, astute and witty, review! I also loved Ashfall and Ashen Winter. Just bought Darla's story. Love your writing!
Susan, I just showed your comment from yesterday to Mike. He said, "awww." I think you made his day. Thanks for your support. Look for Sunrise (book 3) and there's a fourth book under contract. :)




