| Episode cast overview, first billed only: | |||
| Kristen Bell | ... | Eleanor Shellstrop | |
| William Jackson Harper | ... | Chidi Anagonye | |
| Jameela Jamil | ... | Tahani Al-Jamil | |
| D'Arcy Carden | ... | Janet / Neutral Janet / Eleanor Shellstrop / Chidi Anagonye / Tahani Al-Jamil / Jason Mendoza | |
| Manny Jacinto | ... | Jason Mendoza | |
| Ted Danson | ... | Michael | |
| Stephen Merchant | ... | Neil | |
| Eugene Cordero | ... | Pillboi | |
| Brad Morris | ... | Matt | |
|
|
Monica Padman | ... | Eleanor-1 |
| Michael Hagiwara | ... | Eleanor-2 | |
| Mac Jarman | ... | Eleanor-3 | |
| Carol Herman | ... | Eleanor-4 | |
| Lauryn Speights | ... | Eleanor-5 | |
| Sean Riley Smith | ... | Eleanor-6 | |
Eleanor, Chidi, Tahani and Jason are now in Janet's world, an endless void, made necessary when Shawn's minion demons came a calling out of his makeshift portal. It's up to her to protect them while Michael tries to get information on just how the points system works for Good Place/Bad Place separation from the former's accountant who assigns said points. Written by Paul Hanlin
This is a brilliant, hilarious episode of television featuring a tour de force performance from D'Arcy Carden. Not many actors can convincingly embody their fellow castmates' well defined characters, and she does it spectacularly. Carden was seriously robbed of an Emmy nomination for this one. The script (which was nominated) is hilarious and especially features some fantastic moments for Jason-Janet. It's also a huge episode that sets up the rest of the season.
Easily one of my favorite episodes of the series to date. And I cannot emphasize this enough: D'ARCY. DESERVED. AN. EMMY.