Comments for Africa Check https://africacheck.org Africa's first independent fact-checking organisation. Launched in 2012 to promote accuracy in public debate & keep politicians honest. Tue, 11 Jun 2019 10:31:55 +0000 hourly 1 Comment on Three in four Nigerian women use skin-lighteners? No data supports claim by Maci https://africacheck.org/reports/three-in-four-nigerian-women-use-skin-lighteners-no-data-supports-claim/#comment-176741 Tue, 11 Jun 2019 10:31:55 +0000 https://africacheck.org/?post_type=reports&p=24187#comment-176741 This just goes to show that Africa’s biggest enemies are it’s most educated when they fall over themselves to have their name in the western media by conducting bogus experiments that bring results that fit the west’s demonizing narrative of Africa….Such a shame. I am VERY sure if I or anyone were to go to any market today in Lagos, you will not find 77% of traders using bleaching creams. I just cannot believe the level our people will sink to for their own selfish ends…smh

]>
Comment on Quick read: South Africa’s 2019 election in numbers by Pisskak Poopants https://africacheck.org/reports/quick-read-south-africas-2019-election-in-numbers/#comment-175675 Wed, 29 May 2019 10:59:09 +0000 https://africacheck.org/?post_type=reports&p=25001#comment-175675 > 235,472: The number of spoiled votes. Voting for more than one party or writing anything on the ballot paper results in a spoilt vote. It can’t be counted because the voter’s intention is unclear.

> But there’s no information on how many votes were spoiled on purpose or in error as the IEC does not research this, Tsile Maswanganyi, a spokesperson, told Africa Check.

This is very dumb though. If I wrote on my ballot “you all suck too much to earn my vote” it is crystal clear that the vote was spoiled on purpose and not because of my illiteracy!

]>
Comment on Levels of child sexual abuse in South Africa even higher than activist claimed by Martin Pelders https://africacheck.org/reports/levels-child-sexual-abuse-south-africa-even-higher-activist-claimed/#comment-172625 Wed, 08 May 2019 09:42:36 +0000 https://africacheck.org/?post_type=reports&p=11389#comment-172625 Hi
In 2008 there was a study published called (13895 reasons for equity in health) Neil Andersson and Ari Ho-Foster.
This was a huge study. 126000 boys aged 6 to 18. 1900 odd schools in 9 provinces and in 9 official languages.

Results were. 10% of all boys had suffered sexual abuse in the year of the study.
44% of the boys aged 18 in the year of the study (13895) had suffered sexual abuse before age 18
41% of the perpetrators were women
27% of the perpetrators were both male and female
32% of the perpetrators were men.

The scary fact was that these boys were 4 X more likely to perpetrate a rape

I don’t know why this study is not published or cited more, it is a good insight into why our country is the rape capital of the world.

]>
Comment on ANALYSIS: Was Zimbabwe ever the breadbasket of Africa? by Tirivangani https://africacheck.org/2017/11/28/analysis-zimbabwe-ever-breadbasket-africa/#comment-172607 Wed, 08 May 2019 07:56:31 +0000 https://africacheck.org/?p=14701#comment-172607 Was Zimbabwe considered the bread basket of SADCC on the basis of total food production only? Did they not consider productivity in key crops? Did they not consider investments in agriculture then? The article would have done better if it had given an overview of what each of the nine member states in the SADCC grouping were responsible for. With a clear understanding of that, the tone of this article will change.

]>
Comment on HISTORY-CHECK: Was Hamilton Naki directly involved with the first heart transplant? by Richard Mabena https://africacheck.org/2017/03/24/history-check-hamilton-naki-directly-involved-first-heart-transplant/#comment-171061 Thu, 02 May 2019 13:53:36 +0000 https://africacheck.org/?p=10491#comment-171061 Besides his experience, talents, knowledge and skills; why was Dr. Naki excluded f4om this historic occassion? If that that was the case at all.

]>
Comment on Is Zimbabwe’s adult literacy rate the highest in Africa? by D. F. Mandengenda https://africacheck.org/reports/is-zimbabwes-adult-literacy-rate-the-highest-in-africa/#comment-169415 Mon, 29 Apr 2019 11:03:27 +0000 https://africacheck.org/?post_type=reports&p=5644#comment-169415 It’s interesting to note that there is contradiction by the author of the literacy report. First they are relying on estimates from adjusted factual 2011 Zimbabwe demographic and health survey and in the following sentences say this data should be used with caution as countries measure literacy differently, says F. Huebler of UNESCO. South Africa uses a method of self assessment?!!!? And is higher than Zimbabwe yet 9 times out of 10 Zimbabwe gets first and second places for SADC countries high schools essay competitions. Check those statistics! Bogles the mind.

]>
Comment on Is nuclear energy really the ‘cheapest source of electricity’? by Dave https://africacheck.org/reports/is-nuclear-energy-really-the-cheapest-source-of-electricity/#comment-168493 Sat, 27 Apr 2019 13:25:55 +0000 https://africacheck.org/?post_type=reports&p=8751#comment-168493 A few follow up questions:

In relation to nuclear vs the gas + solar plan, what are the carbon emission differences between the two, when you include mining and initial production costs.

For solar, did you include the increased infrastructure costs? Such as battery, and increased transmission costs due to location and geographic set up, and load adjusting in relation to different outputs at different times?

]>
Comment on Do prisoners have access to better medical facilities than the public? by Karen Vitale https://africacheck.org/reports/do-prisoners-have-access-to-better-medical-facilities-than-the-public/#comment-167999 Fri, 26 Apr 2019 16:33:06 +0000 https://africacheck.org/?post_type=reports&p=4363#comment-167999 I’m concerned. I have a friend in African prison , US CITIZEN who is in need of medical help. Reading this I’m concerned

]>
Comment on Does Malawi have just 300 doctors for 16 million people? by anonymous https://africacheck.org/reports/does-malawi-have-just-300-doctors-for-16-million-people/#comment-167811 Fri, 26 Apr 2019 08:16:47 +0000 https://africacheck.org/?post_type=reports&p=7691#comment-167811 Having worked as a volunteer Doctor in Malawi I would argue the 300 figure is likely to be more accurate than your article suggests. You can see from the Medical Council of Malawi lists of newly registered Physicians how many of these Doctors are foreign qualified. The majority of these will be Doctors coming to the country for a temporary period (as I did) perhaps to do some voluntary service or to be involved in a project (eg. research, education) before leaving again. Furthermore, since healthcare staff in Malawi are not reliably paid their wages, and can earn more elsewhere, it is thought that the majority of Doctors will (perhaps understandably) leave the country within a few years of qualifying.

Another aspect overlooked in this article is where these Doctors are working. The vast majority of government-run primary healthcare clinics and district hospitals in Malawi have either no Doctors at all, or perhaps one Doctor who is in charge of the running of that hospital, and who’s duties are therefore largely administrative and do not allow room for direct patient care. Many of Malawi’s registered Doctors will be working at private facilities where they are paid reliably and able to earn a better wage than in government hospitals. Of course, private healthcare is beyond the means of all but the wealthiest few in a country as poor as Malawi.

To give a full picture of the healthcare system in Malawi, it is important to note the role of Medical Assistants and Clinical Officers. After all, these professionals are responsible for almost the entirety of frontline care. However, in training Clinical Officers and Medical Assistants, the Ministry of Health in Malawi is attempting to plug a gap in a situation that is desperate. I have a great deal of admiration for many of these individuals – I have worked with them and seen the workload that they are struggling with – but the training, skills and experience of a Medical Assistant or Clinical Officer is not the same as that of a Doctor. It is true that in rural areas (and 97% of Malawi’s population is rural) the majority of emergency procedures, including caesarean sections, are carried out by Clinical Officers but this is a country that has one of the highest rates of peri-natal mortality in the world and the highest level of surgical risk of any country in the world. Effective and safe healthcare requires trained Physicians.

The latest census of Malawi puts the population at a little over 18 million. Whether the number of Doctors is 300 or 600 makes little difference. Either way, that is tens of thousands of people to each Doctor.

]>
Comment on How many countries in Africa? How hard can the question be? by Kay https://africacheck.org/reports/how-many-countries-in-africa-how-hard-can-the-question-be/#comment-166189 Mon, 22 Apr 2019 20:15:40 +0000 https://africacheck.org/?post_type=reports&p=685#comment-166189 Good you included an update. I’d argue there are only 54 countries in Africa.

I so much believe that I wrote 54 in the list I wrote at https//naijapivot.com/african-countries-and-their-capitals.

I’ll visit the sources you referenced and see for myself.

]>