Pass him a mirror
This is a guest post from Israelinurse Seth Freedman has got something right. In his latest article on CiF he rightly says that all Jews remember exactly where we were on the […]
Demonizing the Settlers
Yesterday we were treated to another Seth Freedman abomination entitled Israeli military gives settlers free rein that retraced familiar CiF territory: demonizing the settlers. Perhaps the most fitting response to CiF and […]
Its all in the title: Jewish conspiracy theory on the Tomasky thread
Oftentimes the title of a ‘Comment is Free’ article tells you everything you need to know about the kind of pond life that will be attracted to the comment thread. No more […]
Defending the Indefensible: Whitaker making a fool of himself…again
If you thought that Brian Whitaker, the commissioning editor of “Comment is Free”, could not make more of a fool of himself than he has done so far, then think again. Yesterday in […]
Why I Oppose J Street
This is a guest post by AKUS The J Street conference took place in Washington, DC, this week, and has had the effect, for better or worse, of bringing J Street out […]
Am Israel Chai
A couple of days ago we reported that the Guardian was conducting a poll purportedly to gauge support for J Street. In a rather obvious attempt to skew the results, the Guardian featured a […]
The Pin-Up Girl
This is a guest post by Israelinurse Did the champagne corks pop at The Guardian over the weekend with the announcement that Amira Hass had won a lifetime acheivement award from the […]
Mr. T for Tolerance
Apparently Richard Silverstein has been stirring up trouble at the J Street conference by having an audience member, Hillel Stavis, forcibly removed by security from the “Bloggers” panel. Hillel Stavis runs a […]
“We’re all Hamas now”
So what possessed Guardian staff member BellaM to intervene in the Isi Leibler thread yesterday with the following: BellaM 26 Oct 09, 4:39pm Some people are dragging this debate waay off topic. […]
Enforcing the GWV: the Guardian J Street Poll
The Guardian, which is opposed to just about anything that Israel says or does, is trying to support J Street since it sees it as another way to create a wedge between […]
Three Misguided Idiots: A Play in Two Acts
Georgina Henry recently made her worst decision so far by attempting to excuse and apologise for an ill-judged and reprehensible by line for an article by Michael Lerner on CiF in which […]
‘Seven Jewish Children’ in Bolton (or Octagone to the PSC?)
This is a guest post by Jonathan Hoffman “Seven Jewish Children” is the antisemitic play that was written by PSC Patron Caryl Churchill after Operation Cast Lead. CiF Watch readers will not […]
The View into Gaza
This is a guest post by AKUS We hear an awful lot on CiF about the destruction in Gaza, most recently from Judge Goldstone, apparently since CiF is one of the few […]
The CiF Routine
CiF-veterans knew what to expect when the Guardian published Harold Evans’ critique of the Goldstone report, which Evans condemned as “A moral atrocity”. Obviously, this sound verdict could only elicit howls of […]
Stratification of Antisemitism at the Guardian
This is a cross-post from Yaacov Lozowick’s Ruminations (for those of you not familiar with Yaacov Lozowick, he is the author of the highly recommended book, Right to Exist, A Moral Defense […]
Follow us on Twitter
CiF Watch recently established a Twitter account. If you’re interested in finding out the latest goings on at ‘Comment is Free’ and have a Twitter account, follow us on Twitter at http://www.twitter.com/cifwatch. […]
Debating the Holocaust on CiF
‘Comment is Free’ is no stranger to Holocaust denial. We recently reported how on Rosh Hashanah, the Jewish New Year, the Guardianistas were running amok denying the Holocaust when the Guardian reported […]
Georgina’s Cretinous Double Standards
Yesterday, we were graced with the presence of none other than Georgina Henry on the Michael Lerner thread. For those of you that don’t know, Georgina is head of ‘Comment is Free’ […]
“Shit the Guardian is Burning”
“Shit the Guardian is Burning” were the ending words of the “Guardians of Iran” an article by The Alchemist published on CiF Watch yesterday and I cannot think of a more apt […]



Recent Comments