Friday

15th Jul 2016

Opinion

Rubble and dust: 
How EU keeps failing Palestinians

  • Bedouin village in south Hebron hills (Photo: Rosie Gabrielle)

All over the occupied West Bank, one can practically taste the dust in the air: since January 2016 some 300 Palestinians homes and structures have been bulldozed by Israeli authorities. Hundreds have lost their homes to such demolitions, more than half of them children.

This cruelty is not random: it is part of a broader strategy by Israel to push Palestinians out of parts of their homeland and further fragment their lands. The aim is to consolidate Israeli control while making room for the further expansion of Israeli settlements.

Dear EUobserver reader

Subscribe now for unrestricted access to EUobserver.

Sign up for 30 days' free trial, no obligation. Full subscription only 15 € / month or 150 € / year.

  1. Unlimited access on desktop and mobile
  2. All premium articles, analysis, commentary and investigations
  3. EUobserver archives

EUobserver is the only independent news media covering EU affairs in Brussels and all 28 member states.

♡ We value your support.

If you already have an account click here to login.

  • Demolition of a structure in the village of Ein al-Meyteh in the Jordan Valley, in August, 2015 (Photo: Aref Daraghmeh, B’Tselem)

The occupation wields the power of a planning regime that cites a hodgepodge of excuses couched in legalese to designate as illegal virtually any Palestinian construction, thereby providing a guise of legality for green-lighting Israeli settlements while bulldozing Palestinian hamlets.

None of this is new. Waves of demolitions come and go, rising and ebbing with the tides of international attention, but never quite stopping. Yet the current wave of demolitions is unique in some ways.

First, in scale: in the first few months of 2016, Israel has already demolished more Palestinian homes than in all of 2015.

Second, in the increased targeting of projects donated to Palestinian communities by the EU and its member states, which include humanitarian aid such as solar panels that provide electricity when Israel prevents hookups to nearby power grids, water cisterns, a pre-fab for a classroom, and basic shelters.

Oddly enough Israel claims that these solar panels and water cisterns, built on land it has occupied since 1967, “undermine its sovereignty”.

In September 2015, the EU initiated a so called ‘structured dialogue’ with Israel, aimed at bringing an end to the demolitions within six months.

No European impact

The EU and its member states also committed to claiming financial compensation from Israel for European-funded projects if the effort failed. Yet far from being halted, demolitions were dramatically stepped up during this period of supposed “dialogue”.

The six months were up more than a month ago. Clearly, the only thing that was structured during this ‘structured dialogue’ was the apparent specific targeting of EU-funded structures. So that even in the bulldozed rubble of an EU-funded playground for Palestinian children one can find some structure – that of the outlines of an Israeli strategy to forcefully displace Palestinians within the occupied territory.

This outrage must not be allowed to go on. The fact that so much of what is being destroyed is funded by European donors only adds insult to injury, with the core issue remaining the loss of human shelter, of people’s homes.

If allowed to continue, thousands of Palestinians in the West Bank – not “mere” hundreds – will lose their homes this year.

What would you call a regime that systematically destroys or confiscates even first aid response, such as tents for families to shelter in? What impact should these actions by a friendly government have on diplomatic and economic relations?

The European answer to date has been: no impact at all. True, statements condemning demolitions have taken an increasingly clearer tone of late, but the bottom line remains the same: statements alone, absent of action, continue to serve as an implicit green light for Israel to proceed unchecked. And Israel does.

The choice is clear

While Israel continues demolishing Palestinian homes, Europe continues to fail Palestinian children, families, and communities, as well as its own people, the true contributors of many of these demolished projects.

This is an urgent plea to take action and make a difference. It is hardly likely that steps such as demanding compensation and making public the cost of demolished donor-structures will be sufficient to bring the demolitions to a halt, but at this stage it is not clear if even such basic measures will be enacted.

The structured dialogue is over, and to no avail. Six months have been wasted – well, not entirely: Israel has used the time well, to further advance its structured demolitions. Amongst the rubble, words have lost their meaning.

The choice is clear: will Europe continue to provide Israel with the go-ahead for further violations of international humanitarian law and a policy of forced displacement? Too much rubble has already settled on the ground, too much dust already clouds the future. The time for words has long passed: it is time to, finally, take action.

Hagai El-Ad
 is the executive director of B’Tselem - The Israeli Information Center for Human Rights in the Occupied Territories.

Column / Brexit Briefing

Brexit plans missing in action

The Brexit referendum has created an almighty political and economic mess, with little sign of a British or EU plan to clean things up.

Opinion

Brexit seed was planted in 2004

The clause allowing a member state to leave the EU was introduced at a time of prosperity. EU leaders should not repeat the mistake and use the crisis to reinforce eurozone membership.

News in Brief

  1. Hollande: the sooner Brexit comes, the better for EU-UK relations
  2. French foreign minister says Johnson 'told lies'
  3. EU commissioner 'doubts' Google will offer her a job
  4. EU files fresh anti-trust cases against Google
  5. MEP requests Dieselgate documents as private citizen
  6. France to present 'Europe of defence' initative
  7. Angela Merkel gets a pay rise
  8. France calls on Barroso to quit Goldman Sachs job

Stakeholders' Highlights

  1. GoogleEU-US Privacy Shield: Restoring Faith in Data Flows and Transatlantic Relations
  2. World VisionWorld Leaders & Youth Advocates Launch Partnership to End Violence Vs. Children
  3. Counter BalanceReport: Institutionalised Corruption in Romania's Third Largest Company
  4. Access NowEuropol Supports Encryption. We Can Relax Now… Right?
  5. GoogleLearn about Google's projects across Europe on Twitter @GoogleBrussels
  6. Access NowPrivacy Shield: Third Unlawful Instrument to Be Approved by EU This Year
  7. Christian Solidarity WorldwideBangladesh: Concerns About Rise Of Violent Extremism
  8. European Healthy Lifestyle AllianceThe Detrimental Health Consequences of Chronic Overconsumption of SSBs
  9. Mission of China to the EUExploring the Nature of the South China Sea Issue
  10. Ciel, Client Earth, HEALEU Commission Crosses Parliament’s Red Lines on TTIP, Say Over 65 Organisations
  11. Eurocommerce, FEBA, Food & Drink EuropeEvery Meal Matters - Food Banks and Business Together to Promote Food Donation
  12. Centre Maurits Coppieters"Austerity led to British leave vote” - Opinion by Miguel Martinez Tomey on #Brexit

Latest News

  1. EU files new antitrust case against Google
  2. Spain stuck between EU sanctions and political deadlock
  3. Calais mayor says UK border deal must be part of Brexit talks
  4. EU 'must lift lid' on secretive 'deal-making'
  5. Theresa May's first steps pose problems for EU
  6. Nato and Russia seek to defuse Baltic tensions
  7. EU plans tougher asylum rules
  8. EU Commission clashes with Parliament on US visas